Meal Planning
More Tools
About Yummly
®/™©2024 Yummly. All rights reserved.
Yummly User: "this is my new go to peanut butter cookie recipe…" Read More
11Ingredients
25Minutes
410Calories
Add to Meal Planner
Add to Meal Planner
Description
With this recipe you can enjoy peanut butter cookies at their very best: soft and chewy in the centers, crispy at the edges, crackly on top, and warm from the oven. The recipe is a Yummly original created by Sara Mellas.
Ingredients
US|METRIC
10 SERVINGS
- 1/4 cup granulated sugar (for coating dough balls)
- 3/4 cup unsalted butter (softened)
- 1/2 cup creamy peanut butter
- 1/2 cup granulated sugar (for cookie dough)
- 1/2 cup light brown sugar (firmly packed)
- 1 Tbsp. honey
- 1 large eggs
- 1 1/2 tsp. vanilla extract
- 2 cups all-purpose flour
- 1 tsp. baking soda
- 1/4 tsp. salt
Did you make this?
Add All to Shopping List
Add to Meal Planner
Directions
- Line two baking sheets with silicone baking mats or parchment paper. Set aside.
- Place the sugar for coating the dough balls in a small bowl. Set aside.
- Preheat the oven to 350°F.
NutritionView More
Unlock full nutritional details with subscription
410Calories
Sodium
Fat
Carbs
Fiber
Potassium
Calories410Calories from Fat190 |
% DAILY VALUE |
Total Fat21g32% |
Saturated Fat10g50% |
Trans Fat |
Cholesterol60mg20% |
Sodium260mg11% |
Potassium140mg4% |
Protein7g |
Calories from Fat190 |
% DAILY VALUE |
Total Carbohydrate49g16% |
Dietary Fiber2g8% |
Sugars29g |
Vitamin A10% |
Vitamin C0% |
Calcium4% |
Iron10% |
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your Daily Values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.
Notes
Add Note
Jot it down
Subscribe to Yummly to add notes
Reviews(87)
Yummly User a month ago
this is my new go to peanut butter cookie recipe!! it's so simple and easy to customize. I added some chocolate chips and crumbled bacon this time and they were delicious 😊
Yummly User 2 months ago
Easy and delicious! I used cinnamon and sugar to coat the dough balls and they turned out fantastic
Yummly User 9 months ago
turned out really well only criticism I have is what to use to scoop the dough out of the ball a teaspoon, table spoon, cookie scoop or even an ice cream scoop, what would have been the best tool? because I had 3 baking sheets of cookies not 2 because I guess I did mine smaller.
Yummly User a year ago
soft on the inside crunchy on the out, love this recipe!
Yummly User 2 years ago
Flavor was good, but they were too dry. I would alter it next time. Also, I added two milk chocolate chips on top for flare and chocolate goodness.
Yummly User 3 years ago
they turned into cupcakes because of the amount of flour that is used, but apartment from that, no complaints really!
Yummly User 3 years ago
Good recipe but even better with chocolate chips
Yummly User 3 years ago
These cookies are absolutely amazing! Especially for my first time ever cooking from scratch. 10 out of 10 best cookies i have ever tasted/made!
Yummly User 3 years ago
still working on the timing, but these are a winner.
Yummly User 3 years ago
It was OK, nothing special
Yummly User 3 years ago
Great cookie!
I would make it again!
Yummly User 3 years ago
they tasted amazing please bake more recipes
Yummly User 3 years ago
perfect i will make it again
Yummly User 3 years ago
Simple to make and very delicious.!
Yummly User 4 years ago
My husband's new FAV!
Yummly User 4 years ago
Added extra 1/4 cup peanut butter and they were fantastic!
Yummly User 4 years ago
needs more peanut butter
Yummly User 4 years ago
They were sooo good! I reduced the amount of sugar and ended up using waaay more flour, not sure why tho
Yummly User 4 years ago
These turned out super well! My only gripe is that they didn’t taste as peanutty as I wanted.
Yummly User 4 years ago
The texture was great (not too soft or bendy), and I would definitely make this again
Yummly User 4 years ago
Great cookies! I would make this again. Perfect texture.
Yummly User 4 years ago
Amazing 😊 I had to add a bit more flour, but this may be because I was using extra creamy peanut butter.
Yummly User 4 years ago
Made it with my son. I don't eat sweets, but he seems to dig it
Yummly User 4 years ago
These are very good. I went a little easy on the white sugar and doubled the amount of salt (and used half table salt, half kosher salt). I was able to get the criss cross pattern. I wouldn’t call these chewy, more soft and a little crumbly, though maybe they’ll be chewier when stale. If you’re just looking for a delicious standard PB cookie, this is a good one!
Yummly User 4 years ago
Amazing. I cooked mine for 15 minutes. They were crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. I put two pans in at a time because I like mine extra crispy. The top tray was absolutely more crunchy! I could not get them to criss cross like usual peanut butter cookies, so I kind of just smooshed them down! Very Yummy and easy to make!
Yummly User 4 years ago
Turned out great! I made more than the recipe’s expected 20 cookies. Also used a bit more salt than recommended, and sprinkled the leftover sugar over the cookies before baking. My Lovely Wife said, “ I hate you. These are perfect.” LoL
Yummly User 4 years ago
They were good they could be left i there probably for 15 min I did for 12 and were a little under cooked
Yummly User 4 years ago
Not super sweet, which is great. I substituted 1 c flour with 1/3 c coconut flour and used Jif pb. Probably could have added more salt and peanutbutter to give it a stronger flavor. I've definitely had better peanutbutter cookies but this wasn't too bad.
Yummly User 4 years ago
Ehh. They were good. But very very dry and needed more peanut butter flavor. I added more peanut butter and milk to my second batch to make them a little more moist.
Yummly User 4 years ago
Easy but slightly too sweet. I would definitely reduce the sugar. Texture is perfect. The chopped hazelnuts I added fit great as well!